(Promotional) - Pre-employment assessment, skill testing and interviewing

We often hear terms like pre-employment assessment, skill testing and even interviewing used interchangeably. While they may have similar high level goals, such as identifying a suitable candidate, they are fundamentally different methods of achieving those goals. It’s important to know the difference because each evaluation method will produce completely different outputs. Moreover, in some cases it might make sense to combine one or more of these methods.

One of the best discussions I’ve heard on this topic was on a podcast called Hire Up hosted by John P. Beck, Jr. The episode was titled Assessments Made Simple, Human, Smart and featured Dr. Scott Hamilton, the CEO of Hamilton & Associates Consulting.

Dr. Hamilton distinguished between each candidate evaluation method with ease and clarity. It’s worth listening to the entire episode but, otherwise, I have summarized some of the key points in this article and added my own thoughts as well.


Skill testing

Skill testing is all about understanding whether someone can do something or knows something. It can be a simple task, a range of complex tasks or demonstrable knowledge. It’s possible to test for almost any skill because you can simply watch people perform tasks.

Dr. Hamilton gives the simplest of examples: “if someone is going to have to weld metal, you want see them weld metal”.

This is why résumés and interviews are inherently poor methods of validating skills. They are focused on what candidates claim they can do, not what they can actually do. Instead, it’s far more compelling to see how people perform. Literally. Moreover, it’s far simpler.

Skill testing is context-dependent, and therefore subjective in nature. But it’s also capable of being objectively assessed, which means it can be pass/fail. Confusing, right?

Let’s take a writing test as an example. The style of writing you test depends entirely on the job. It could be anything from creative writing to technical writing. So the test is bespoke. At the same time, it is usually possible to objectively determine whether a candidate performed well. To use Dr. Hamilton’s welding example, either someone knows how to weld metal or they don’t.

The opposite is usually true of pre-employment assessment.


Pre-employment assessment: what is it?

Pre-employment assessment is focused on predicting how people will behave in certain scenarios, not what they can do. They explore key personality traits based on an understanding that someone’s personality can predict their behaviour. Most personality assessments are based on the Five-Factor Model, which asserts that there are five personality supertraits:

  • Openness to experience
  • Conscientiousness
  • Extraversion
  • Agreeableness
  • Neuroticism

Therefore, if we gain an understanding of someone’s personality, and particularly these five supertraits, we will have a good chance of knowing how they will react in different situations. Unlike skill testing, this doesn’t mean someone can do the job. But it may shed light on how they will do the job.


Pre-employment assessment: does personality change?

Now here’s the tricky part. While skills can be taught, many people think that personality is fixed. However, that isn’t entirely true. Studies have shown that personality can, and does, change over time. While most people don’t change in a fundamental way, it is possible to change behaviors and habits, according to Carol Dweck. And it’s those very behaviors that are relevant to how someone will perform in a job, not their personality per se. That’s why two people with different personalities can perform well in the same role.

Whether we believe personality is fixed or not, it is not something that can be measured in binary terms such as pass/fail, like an Excel test. It’s who we are and, if we subscribe to the theory that personality changes over time, it’s who are are at the time of assessment. This means that the outcome of a personality assessment can’t be viewed as “good” or “bad” in isolation, it can only indicate potential suitability for a specific job. Conversely, someone can be good at Excel.





Additionally, if used incorrectly, personality assessments can be harmful to the hiring process. That’s why pre-employment assessments that test personality need to be validated. Skill testing, on the other hand, is inherently bespoke.

What does this all mean?

This is where it gets interesting. Let’s start with the dictionary:

  • A test means “a procedure intended to establish the quality, performance, or reliability of something, especially before it is taken into widespread use”.
  • To assess means  to “evaluate or estimate the nature, ability, or quality of”.
  • An interview means “A meeting of people face to face, especially for consultation”.

Interviewing

Tests and assessments sound fairly similar. They are ways of measuring ability or quality. On the other hand, an interview is a discussion. Technology also makes it possible to conduct one-way interviews using video, which are essentially discussions without real-time interaction. And yet, the most commonly used method for making hiring decisions is interviewing. For some reason the notion that skills and behaviors can be evaluated without skill tests or assessments – but through a discussion – has become the norm.

Maybe it’s because of a lack of resourcing. Maybe we trust our intuition more than third party methods. Or maybe it’s a lack of awareness. But it doesn’t make a lot of sense because interviews don’t predict performance. They typically focus on understanding what someone did in the past or discussing what they claim to be able to do, without proof.

Can interviews nevertheless play a valuable role in the hiring process? Interviews should be used to get to know a preferred candidate after their skills and behaviors have been validated. Only candidates who have already demonstrated they can do they job should be interviewed. That would allow for a much more valuable interviewing experience, and a far better use of everyone’s time. Unfortunately, that is not normally the case.

Can we combine skill testing, pre-employment assessment and interviewing?

A strong hiring process will combine reliable insights about a candidate’s ability to do the job and their expected behavior with high-quality human interaction. In theory, this could involve a skill test, some form of pre-employment assessment and an interview. It very much depends on the type of role, and the candidate experience the company wants to deliver.

Hiring is not a “one size fits all” endeavour. Every situation is different. But understanding what each evaluation method can achieve and, more importantly, what it will not achieve, will go a long way to helping companies build hiring robust processes. 




AUTHOR

Omer Molad
Making hiring about merit, not background | Co-founder and CEO of Vervoe

38 Comments

  1. My friend website has been infected with malware. The tips shared in this post helps me in a better way and guide me to protect my website.
    Hire a Coder
    Hire PHP Developer India
    Hire Opencart Developer
    Hire Wordpress Programmer
    Hire Magento Developer

    ReplyDelete
  2. I’m impressed with the post which you have shared. This is very informative to know the benefits of outsourcing web development services.
    Dedicated Magento Developer
    Hire Cake Php Programmer
    Hire Dedicated Laravel Developer
    Hire Phonegap Developer
    Hire Cake Php Developer

    ReplyDelete
  3. I read your post and got it quite informative. I couldn't find any knowledge on this matter prior to. I would like to thanks for sharing this article here. hrhelper is the best online platform where you can Create Casual Employment Contract at an affordable price.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Outstanding in addition to effective suggestion by the author of this blog are genuinely sensible to me. Healthcare Homework Writing

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really got to know many things from this blog. It will help me to prepare for my pre-employment assessment test. Thanks a lot for sharing the article.

    Regards,
    Yorvitech Solutions Pvt. Ltd

    ReplyDelete
  6. We believe in offering UX and UI that stands out in respect of ease of use, engagement and attributes that make apps ready to cope up with the future changes quickly. We built many of the most versatile and flexible Android apps for a diverse array of business niches. From the robust pool of talented Android app developers for hire to a proven track record of making a significant contribution to companies with our mobile development, there are many reasons to choose us for your Android app development project or to hire indian app developers from us.

    ReplyDelete
  7. High technologies solutions provides the best tally training in Delhi with 100% placement.Trainers are subject specialist and corporate professionals providing in-depth study. 100% placement guaranteed.For free demo class call at +919311002620.
    Tally training institute delhi
    Tally training institute in Noida

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very interesting information and very useful topic. I have information regarding data science course in Chennai.
    data-science training
    Data-Analytics course
    business analytics -Python course

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great post i must say and thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.

    AI Course in malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  10. I read this article, it is really informative one. Your way of writing and making things clear is very impressive. Thanking you for such an informative article. pre employment background check

    ReplyDelete
  11. There are a lot of advantages of Python making it different from others. Its applications have made it a demanded language for software development, web development, graphic designing and other use cases. Its standard libraries which support internet unindent does not match any outer indentation level

    ReplyDelete
  12. But the furious and fast pace at which technology grew brought about a sea-change in the very perspective of website design and development. Jake Hackett

    ReplyDelete
  13. It is really a great and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
    PMP Certification In Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  14. The same happens with your company, the more transparent your product or service is, the better your audience will accept it. weblink

    ReplyDelete
  15. Nice blog post so thanks a lot for sharing this great blog post.. keep more post for sharing.. have a nice day.
    Real Estate Lawyer in Cambridge

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very nice post, impressive. its quite different from other posts. Thanks for sharing.
    Express Entry Lawyer in Canada

    ReplyDelete
  17. Use our Mortgage Payment Frequency Calculator Canada to determine your payment or loan amount for different payment frequencies. Mortgage Payment Frequency Calculator Canada

    ReplyDelete
  18. The first-time home buyer’s tax credit allows you to claim back $750 on your tax return after buying your first home in Canada. what you need to know. Tax Credit For First Time Home Buyers

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you live in Prince Edward Island, British Columbia or Ontario then you might qualify for the land transfer tax rebate. what you need to know.Land transfer tax rebate calculator

    ReplyDelete
  20. A home buying guide for first-time buyers with current information and calculators and every step of the buying process. Home Buying Process in Canada

    ReplyDelete
  21. It might hurt because it gives the customer a wrong impression of the product and the brand. The advertising potential of product packaging is one of its significant benefits in the contemporary marketplace. BOPA film manufacturer/supplier

    ReplyDelete
  22. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You
    have done a extraordinary job!
    Bulk Email Sending Service Provider

    ReplyDelete
  23. I read the above article and got some knowledge from your article which is about..... It's actually great and useful data for us. Thanks for sharing it.web development

    ReplyDelete
  24. The knowledge in this article taught me a great deal aboutfree esignature appBoth educational and helpful, the article. We appreciate you sharing this knowledge. Keep up the excellent work.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I read the article you linked to above, and I learned a little something from it. For us, the information is genuinely quite good and helpful. We appreciate you sharing it.hire programmers in india

    ReplyDelete
  26. I found decent information in your article. I am impressed with how nicely you described electronic signature, It is a gainful article for us. Thanks for share it.

    ReplyDelete
  27. We've noticed that this article is well-informed, in my opinion. The essay is beneficial to us, and your writing is exceptional. We appreciate you sharing this content.hire coldfusion developers

    ReplyDelete
  28. Trust Connect Infosoft Technologies for all your Laravel development requirements and experience the power of cutting-edge technology combined with unmatched customer satisfaction. Contact us today and let us transform your vision into reality.
    Laravel Development Team in India

    ReplyDelete
  29. If you're aspiring to become a skilled software tester and seeking a top-quality institute in Noida, APTRON Solution Noida should be at the top of your list. With its industry-aligned curriculum, experienced faculty, and commitment to student success, the institute offers an ideal platform to kickstart your career in the field of Software Testing Institute in Noida. Embrace the opportunity to learn, grow, and thrive with APTRON Solution Noida. Your journey toward a rewarding software testing career begins here.

    ReplyDelete
Previous Post Next Post